Hiring for paid media in the AI age requires a mindset shift. Most hiring checklists are still stuck in 2017, focusing on experience or single-channel mastery. But today, marketers who can outpace algorithms and competitors alike are those who combine curiosity, creativity, and adaptability. Whether you’re building a performance marketing team for an agency or assembling an in-house squad, the rise of AI in advertising—from automated bidding to generative content tools—has changed the game.

If your hiring practices haven’t evolved, you’re leaving your team vulnerable. The smartest marketers now operate across multiple channels, leverage AI strategically, and focus on user journeys instead of just ad groups. In this article, we’ll explore the attributes of top-tier paid media professionals in the AI age and why they’re more important than ever.

From Single-Channel Experts to Multi-Channel Innovators

In past years, hiring for deep expertise in one channel—like paid search—was a common practice. In the AI age, this approach is increasingly outdated. AI has permeated every major platform, automating many tactical advantages that once gave specialists an edge.

Marketers who thrive today take a holistic view of multi-channel campaigns. They understand user behavior across paid search, social media, and emerging platforms. Single-channel silos limit growth, whereas adaptable marketers can pivot strategies based on platform updates and AI-driven insights.

Experience still matters, but only when combined with the willingness to broaden one’s skill set. Candidates who refuse to explore other channels may struggle to deliver impact in today’s fast-moving paid media environment.

Curiosity with Skepticism: The AI Filter

AI tools are everywhere—from bid optimization algorithms to LLMs generating ad copy. But overreliance on technology can be dangerous. Top performers approach every tool with curiosity and skepticism.

They ask:

• What data is the tool pulling from?
• Which model underpins it?
• Are all account variables considered?
• Does it provide long-term growth potential, or is it a quick fix?

These questions help teams avoid wasted spend and over-committed contracts. In a rapidly evolving landscape, flexibility and discernment are just as critical as technical skill.

Experience Matters—But Flexibility Is Key

Years in the industry can be an asset, but in the AI age, experience alone isn’t enough. Many experienced marketers struggle when asked to adapt to new tools, platforms, or AI-driven strategies.

The ideal candidate combines foundational marketing knowledge with adaptability. They understand principles like audience segmentation, funnel strategy, and ROI measurement but can also evolve as platforms and AI capabilities change. Teams benefit most from marketers whose experience informs decision-making without constraining innovation.

Communication and Empathy: Human Skills That AI Can’t Replace

Even as AI automates repetitive tasks, human communication remains irreplaceable. Clear, empathetic communication ensures that team members understand objectives and that clients feel heard.

In agencies and in-house teams alike, empathy fosters collaboration, builds trust, and improves results. AI can generate content, but it cannot anticipate client priorities, read interpersonal cues, or adapt KPIs to shifting business goals. In the AI age, communication skills are not a “nice-to-have”; they’re a strategic advantage.

Creativity: The Differentiator in the AI Age

Optimization alone isn’t enough to stand out. While AI can generate text, creatives, and test variations, it cannot replace human ingenuity. Campaigns that succeed in the AI age often involve creative strategies that anticipate market trends, experiment with novel ideas, and adapt messaging to audience psychology.

Marketers who can ideate beyond small A/B tests—developing themes, storytelling angles, and innovative visuals—are critical to scaling paid media campaigns. Creativity, combined with analytics, transforms data insights into high-performing campaigns.

Balancing Analytics and Imagination

Some marketers lean heavily on analytics, while others prioritize creative execution. In today’s AI age, the balance tips slightly toward creativity, but analytics remain essential. Candidates should:

• Understand performance metrics across channels
• Analyze data to identify insights and opportunities
• Translate results into actionable strategies

Analytical skills ensure campaigns are data-driven, while creativity enables differentiation in crowded markets. The best hires integrate both disciplines seamlessly.

Avoiding the AI Trap: Hiring for Skill, Not Hype

It’s easy to be dazzled by applicants with AI credentials. From prompt engineering to generative content experience, AI is attractive on paper. However, AI proficiency without marketing fundamentals rarely produces results.

Hiring managers should look for candidates who:

• Demonstrate strategic thinking and problem-solving
• Can execute campaigns end-to-end
• Adapt quickly to new AI tools and market trends

In short, paid media expertise still matters—AI is a tool, not a replacement for marketing talent.

Conclusion: Building the Paid Media Teams of Tomorrow

The AI age is transforming how we hire, manage, and scale paid media teams. Success requires marketers who are curious, adaptable, creative, and empathetic. Candidates must navigate multi-channel campaigns, leverage AI tools judiciously, and translate insights into strategic action.

Teams that embrace these qualities won’t just survive in the AI-driven marketing landscape—they’ll lead. By prioritizing curiosity, flexibility, communication, and creativity, hiring managers can build teams capable of outpacing algorithms, outperforming competitors, and shaping the future of paid media.

The bottom line: in a world increasingly influenced by AI, foundational skills combined with forward-thinking adaptability are your competitive advantage. Hire for the AI age, and you’ll create a paid media team that thrives today and tomorrow.

you may also like

Is AI Eating Away at Your SEO Conversion An overview of the 2025 Shift